top of page
  • Writer's pictureSajeev Varghese

"Pathaan": A Spectacular Sacrifice of The Storytelling Craft

Bollywood, where spectacle often trumps substance, "Pathaan" stands as a stark emblem of this adage, attempting to weave an intricate tapestry of espionage and patriotism yet faltering in the very threads that should bind it—story and storytelling craft.

The high-octane action drama, was Shah Rukh Khan's much-anticipated leap back into the limelight, aiming to dazzle with a mix of espionage, patriotism, and super-spy charisma. Yet, despite the star-studded cast and a premise that promised to be as explosive as the biochemical weapon at its heart, "Pathaan" found itself tangled in a web of its own making, unable to break free from the shadows of its predecessors in the "Yash Raj Films Spy Universe."

At the heart of "Pathaan" lies a conceptual paradox: an ambitious spy thriller that underutilizes the very essence of storytelling—believability. The disjointed narrative, embellished with overproduced action sequences that bear the brunt of poor image composition, strains credulity. The attempt to knit together a team of Hindi-language-speaking action heroes, while conceptually intriguing, ends up feeling more like a contrived congregation rather than a coherent ensemble, further exacerbated by scenes where key characters seem dislocated from the action unfolding around them.

The emotional engagement within "Pathaan" remains superficial at best. Characters, including the titular Pathaan, navigate through a narrative that demands a suspension of disbelief so vast that it alienates rather than endears. The character interactions, meant to evoke a spectrum of emotions from camaraderie to romantic tension, often feel stilted, bereft of the chemistry that binds relationships in a narrative fabric. This emotional detachment is mirrored in the audience's experience, where the spectacle fails to compensate for the lack of depth.

Intellectual stimulation, a facet where espionage thrillers have the potential to excel, is notably absent. The plot, with its globe-trotting escapades and high-stakes conflict, could have been a fertile ground for nuanced exploration of themes such as patriotism, morality, and sacrifice. Instead, "Pathaan" opts for a surface-level engagement with these themes, presenting them in a manner that neither challenges the intellect nor invites reflection. The narrative, rather than being a cleverly woven puzzle that the audience is invited to unravel, becomes a predictable trajectory toward an inevitable conclusion.

Relevance and meaningfulness, critical aspects that elevate a story from mere entertainment to a reflective mirror of society, remain elusive. The film's overt nationalism and the simplistic dichotomy it draws between heroism and villainy lack the subtlety and complexity that mark significant storytelling. In an era where cinema is increasingly scrutinized for its portrayal of geopolitics and societal values, "Pathaan" misses the opportunity to contribute meaningfully to these conversations, opting instead for a portrayal that borders on caricature.

Moreover, the storytelling craft itself, the backbone of any cinematic endeavor, appears neglected. The narrative is riddled with clichés and conveniences that undermine its integrity. Characters are reduced to archetypes, their development sacrificed at the altar of spectacle. The dialogue oscillates between the corny and the expository, failing to resonate or reveal. Scenes intended to be pivotal or emotionally charged, instead feel orchestrated and devoid of genuine sentiment.

"Pathaan," for all its ambition and star power, encapsulates the challenges of balancing the spectacle with substance. In its pursuit of grandeur, it overlooks the fundamentals of storytelling, resulting in a film that, while visually captivating, lacks the soul that engages, enlightens, and endures. As it stands, "Pathaan" is a reminder of the intricate dance between story and spectacle, a ballet where missteps are as conspicuous as they are critical.

32 views0 comments


Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page