India, home to the world’s largest and oldest film industry, has long been a global powerhouse for filmmaking. With a cinematic legacy spanning over a century, Indian filmmakers have crafted tales rich in cultural nuance, emotional depth, and universal themes. For decades, Indian cinema, rooted in its regional diversity, showcased storytelling craft that rivaled world-class filmmaking. Films from the golden era of Indian cinema, marked by directors like Guru Dutt, Bimal Roy, and Satyajit Ray, were lauded globally for their artistic brilliance and narrative finesse. Even directors like Ramesh Sippy, Hrishikesh Mukherjee, Shyam Benegal, Gulzar, Basu Chatterjee, etc. of the 1970s and 1980s were no slouch at filmmaking. Read our blog post on "Embracing Gulzar's Legacy: A Call to Action for Filmmakers."
However, this proud legacy has been steadily eroded since the 1980s, when a new crop of filmmakers, predominantly the inheritors of film dynasties, coined the term "Bollywood." What began as a catchy moniker to market Mumbai's Hindi film industry has now become synonymous with a culture of nepotism and mediocrity. These second-generation filmmakers closed ranks, turning the industry into an echo chamber of privilege. The focus shifted from nurturing talent and innovative storytelling to sustaining a cycle of insularity, where family connections mattered more than merit.
This decline coincided with a growing reliance on formulaic plots, star power, and high-octane marketing. While the global film industry evolved to embrace authenticity, complexity, and diversity in storytelling, Bollywood doubled down on creating superficial spectacles targeted at the lowest common denominator. As these filmmakers consolidated their influence, they sidelined creativity and originality, leaving audiences to grapple with films that lacked believability, emotional engagement, and intellectual depth.
What’s more troubling is how this culture of mediocrity has been institutionalized, with many in the current crop of “MegaStars” who are barely able to embody their characters on screen. Acting has become a performance of mimicry and self-indulgence rather than a transformative art. Scripts are tailored to suit these stars’ public personas, ensuring they remain themselves on the screen instead of delivering believable unique multi-dimensional characters, with dynamic performances. Meanwhile, high marketing budgets mask the lack of storytelling craft, creating the illusion of quality while eroding audience trust. Read our blog post on "The Broken Astra: The Storytelling Failure of 'Brahmastra Part One'"
This analysis unpacks how Bollywood’s descent into nepotism, gimmickry, and hollow stardom has become a cautionary tale for Indian cinema. It explores how this insular approach threatens not just Bollywood’s credibility but also the broader Indian film industry, as regional cinema increasingly faces the influence of these toxic practices. Most importantly, this analysis aims to inspire action—by reminding filmmakers of India’s rich legacy, highlighting the immense potential for renewal, and championing the art of storytelling as the true soul of cinema.
Indian cinema has always been a beacon of cultural expression, celebrated for its vibrant stories and emotional depth. But Bollywood, once the pride of Indian cinema, has fallen into a cycle of complacency, arrogance, conceit, and deceit, prioritizing profits over craft. With high-octane marketing masking poorly crafted films and a glaring lack of real talent at the top, Bollywood’s credibility is eroding—and the ripple effects are tarnishing the entire Indian film industry.
The Gimmick Playbook: High Hype, Low Substance
Bollywood’s current modus operandi is disturbingly predictable. Films are marketed with bombastic claims of being "winners" with “outstanding scripts” and “stellar performances.” Take Jug Jugg Jeeyo, for instance, which touted a 9.1/10 IMDb user rating pre-release—only to tumble to 6.1 after the hype faded. Yet even this inflated rating hides manipulation, as user reviews across countries reveal a deliberate effort to boost the film's perception. Liger, Brahmastra, Rocky Aur Rani Kii Prem Kahaani, etc., by the same filmmakers, followed suit with products that were less than mediocre at best. Read our blog post on "Exposing the Truth about Bollywood’s Film Review Manipulation."
The formula? Exploit the least discerning segment of a 1.4-billion-strong population with flashy trailers, massive promotions, and exaggerated claims. Movies like Pathaan have taken this to absurd heights, projecting trailers on the Burj Khalifa and dominating headlines, only to deliver hollow experiences devoid of meaningful storytelling. This isn't filmmaking—it’s a con job. Read our blog post on "Pathaan: A Spectacular Sacrifice of The Storytelling Craft."
Fake Stardom: The Death of Real Talent
Compounding this crisis is the lack of genuine talent at the top. Bollywood’s so-called “MegaStars” demand astronomical fees while offering little in terms of transformative performances. Acting, at its core, is about becoming the character—a process that requires skill, vulnerability, and dedication. Yet these “stars” remain firmly rooted in their off-screen personas, treating films as extended vanity projects.
Scripts are written around these actors, enabling them to stay as themselves on screen rather than embodying believable, multifaceted characters. At best, their performances resemble mimicry or fancy-dress cosplay, far removed from the art of acting. This stagnation not only cheapens the craft but also creates a false hierarchy, where mediocrity is rewarded with fame and wealth, leaving audiences disillusioned and disengaged.
The Storytelling Crisis: The Heart of the Problem
The lack of real talent feeds directly into Bollywood’s storytelling crisis. Films fail to deliver on the core pillars of cinema:
Believability: Characters and narratives feel shallow and artificial.
Emotional Engagement: Audiences are left disconnected from stories that fail to resonate on a deeper level.
Intellectual Stimulation: Themes rarely challenge or inspire critical thought.
Relevance: Stories fail to reflect societal truths or shared universal human experiences.
Meaningfulness: Narratives lack lasting impact, evaporating as soon as the credits roll.
Instead, Bollywood churns out superficial spectacles, relying on star power and visual effects to mask its creative bankruptcy. Read our blog post on "The Pillars of Cinematic Success."
The Ripple Effect: Bollywood’s Toxic Influence
Bollywood’s practices aren’t confined to itself—they’re infecting other Indian film industries. Once bastions of authentic storytelling, regional industries like South Indian cinema are increasingly being targeted by Bollywood’s superficial strategies. In their pursuit of regional audiences, Bollywood studios are exporting their flawed playbook, threatening the integrity and uniqueness of these industries.
A Call to Action: The Industry’s Moment of Reckoning
This is not just Bollywood’s crisis—it’s a wake-up call for the entire Indian film industry. Filmmakers outside Bollywood, especially in regional industries, must take a stand:
Prioritize Storytelling Craft: Embrace narratives that resonate deeply, with authentic characters and meaningful themes.
Reject Fake Stardom: Champion talent that brings characters to life, rather than perpetuating the myth of “MegaStars” who deliver vanity projects.
Uphold Acting as a Craft: Demand performances that reflect dedication to the art of acting, not mimicry or self-indulgence.
Collaborate Intelligently: Engage in partnerships that enhance regional storytelling styles, not dilute them with Bollywood’s toxic influence.
Champion Ethical Filmmaking: Build credibility through honesty and quality, rather than manipulation and hype.
Read our blog post on "Shifting the Spotlight in the Indian Film Industry."
The Opportunity for Renewal
India’s regional film industries—South Indian cinema, Marathi cinema, Bengali cinema, and others—are already proving that great storytelling transcends borders (RRR, The Kashmir Files and The Lunchbox are prime examples). By continuing to champion authenticity and craft, these industries can set new benchmarks for Indian cinema as a whole. The global stage is ready for India’s stories—but they must be told with honesty, heart, and excellence.
A New Era or a Slow Demise?
Bollywood must decide: will it cling to its toxic cycle of gimmicks and fake stardom, or will it embrace the transformative power of genuine storytelling and talent? The stakes couldn’t be higher. For the Indian film industry to reclaim its rightful place as a global powerhouse, it must reject arrogance, rediscover its roots, and lead with integrity. This isn’t just about saving an industry—it’s about restoring the soul of Indian cinema. Read our blog post on "Sholay: A Cinematic Icon and the Evolution of Bollywood Storytelling."
The time has come for the Indian film industry to break free from Bollywood’s shadow. Let this be the moment when storytellers reclaim their craft, when audiences reclaim their trust, and when Indian cinema reclaims its rightful place as a beacon of innovation and authenticity. This is not just about saving an industry—it’s about honoring the power of stories to shape culture, inspire change, and reconnect with humanity.
Proposed Path Forward for the Indian Film Industry
To reclaim its global standing as a leader in cinematic storytelling, the Indian film industry must embark on a transformative journey that prioritizes authenticity, creativity, and excellence. Read our blog post on "Prioritizing Brilliant Storytelling Craft in Indian Filmmaking Over Box-Office Success." This path forward should be rooted in rediscovering the art of storytelling while embracing innovation and global collaboration. Here’s how the industry can progress:
1. Prioritize Storytelling Craft
Invest in Writers: Establish dedicated writing labs and residencies to nurture screenwriting talent. Encourage collaboration between seasoned writers and emerging storytellers to develop scripts with depth and universal appeal.
Champion Authentic Stories: Focus on narratives that are culturally specific yet resonate universally, highlighting diverse regional tales while addressing global themes like identity, migration, and social justice.
Incorporate Research: Base stories on detailed research to ensure authenticity, whether exploring historical events, contemporary issues, or fantasy worlds.
2. Develop and Support Real Talent
Redefine Stardom: Shift the focus from “MegaStars” to versatile actors who can embody diverse characters. Cast based on merit, not connections, and challenge performers to step out of their comfort zones.
Support Transformative Acting: Encourage actors to undergo rigorous preparation, including workshops, method acting, and dialect coaching, to deliver believable performances that immerse audiences.
3. Encourage Innovation in Filmmaking
Experiment with Genres: Break away from formulaic narratives by exploring underutilized genres like psychological thrillers, science fiction, and social realism.
Collaborate Globally: Partner with international filmmakers, writers, and technicians to learn from global practices while showcasing India’s rich storytelling traditions.
4. Commit to Ethical and Transparent Marketing
Earn, Don’t Fabricate, Trust: Move away from high-octane marketing gimmicks and inflated user ratings. Let the quality of the film drive word-of-mouth, building credibility organically.
Audience Education: Engage audiences by promoting the art of storytelling, helping them discern quality content and appreciate films beyond spectacle.
5. Embrace Diversity and Regional Excellence
Leverage Regional Strengths: Promote regional cinemas as flag-bearers of authentic storytelling, rather than imposing Bollywood’s flawed formula. Support regional filmmakers in preserving their unique voices while fostering cross-industry collaborations.
Champion Multilingual Narratives: Develop stories that seamlessly integrate India’s linguistic and cultural diversity, appealing to both domestic and global audiences.
6. Establish Industry Standards for Quality
Certification and Accountability: Create industry standards for evaluating storytelling craft, including narrative complexity, character development, and thematic relevance.
Peer Review: Institute peer-review committees for scripts and finished films to uphold storytelling quality and discourage mediocrity.
Immediate Action Items
Launch a National Storytelling Initiative: Partner with academic institutions, regional industries, and global experts to host workshops, competitions, and conferences focused on the craft of storytelling.
Create a Talent Discovery Program: Introduce a platform for discovering and mentoring writers, directors, and actors from diverse backgrounds, ensuring fresh talent and perspectives.
Reform Awards and Recognition: Shift focus in national awards and film festivals to recognize storytelling excellence, not just box office success or star power.
Audit Marketing Practices: Form an independent body to monitor and prevent manipulative marketing tactics, ensuring transparency and accountability in promoting films.
Invest in International Co-Productions: Collaborate with global studios to create co-productions that marry Indian narratives with international storytelling styles and technical expertise.
A Vision for the Future
By embracing these changes, the Indian film industry can reclaim its legacy as a world-class leader in cinematic storytelling. This transformation will not only elevate the craft of filmmaking but also restore audience trust and inspire a new generation of filmmakers. Indian cinema has always held the potential to bridge cultures and touch hearts globally. Now is the time to realize that potential, crafting stories that are not just seen but deeply felt—stories that redefine India’s place on the cinematic world stage.
Conclusion: The Time for Transformation is Now
Indian cinema stands at a pivotal crossroads—a moment of reckoning where the past meets the promise of the future. With the largest and oldest film industry in the world, we carry the weight of a rich legacy of storytelling that has inspired generations. Yet, in recent decades, Bollywood’s reliance on nepotism, gimmicks, and superficiality has cast a shadow over that legacy, threatening the credibility of an industry once known for its artistry and innovation. This is a transformation imperative, a call to action that demands courage, creativity, and a return to the essence of what makes cinema great. Read our blog post on "Reimagining the Hindi Film Industry: A Blueprint for Revival."
The road forward is not without challenges, but the rewards are unparalleled. By prioritizing storytelling craft, fostering real talent, and embracing authenticity over spectacle, Indian cinema can reclaim its rightful place as a beacon of global storytelling. It’s time to shift the focus from chasing fleeting profits to creating narratives that resonate across borders, transcending cultural barriers while staying rooted in our rich traditions. This is not just about competing on the global stage—it’s about leading it. The timing of the disruption from AI in the filmmaking industry can not be overlooked. Read our blog post on "The AI Advantage: Harnessing ChatGPT to Enhance Storytelling and Filmmaking."
The time for action is now. Let filmmakers, writers, actors, producers, and audiences unite to demand better—to demand stories that move us, performances that transform us, and films that remind the world of Indian cinema’s true potential. The world is watching, and the stage is set for a new era of cinematic excellence. Indian cinema doesn’t just have the opportunity to rise—it has the responsibility to lead. Let’s seize this moment, not just to entertain but to inspire, connect, and create history. After all, the best stories aren’t told—they’re lived. Let’s write the next chapter of Indian cinema, together.
Comments