Indian cinema, the world’s largest and oldest film industry, is known for its vibrant productions and cultural depth. Yet, when we evaluated the 143 Hindi films released in 2024, a stark narrative emerged—one of unfulfilled potential and missed opportunities. While a few gems shine through with meaningful stories and emotional resonance, a significant chunk of these productions fail to meet the mark, plagued by formulaic plots, superficial execution, and an over-reliance on star power. In this analysis, we explore the highs and lows of 2024’s Hindi cinema, evaluating the best and the rest, and uncovering what separates the standout films from the forgettable ones. Let’s dive in.
We analyzed them all from a story and storytelling craft perspective to rate the top 10 on a 0-10 stars scale on believability, emotionally engaging, intellectually compelling, relevant, and meaningful, and graded them based on the standards of world-class cinema for the same with a letter grade. Based on our detailed analysis of the movies released so far in 2024, here are the results:
Key Statistics
Total Hindi Movies Released in 2024 (so far): 143 films
Average Movies Released per Month: Approximately 11.92 (rounded to 12)
Top-Level Statistics for Top 10 Movies
Below is a summary of the top 10 movies we analyzed:
Title | Actors | Producers | Distributors | Rating | Grade |
Merry Christmas | Katrina Kaif, Vijay Sethupathi | Tips Industries, Matchbox Pictures | - | 8.1 | A- |
Main Atal Hoon | Pankaj Tripathi | Bhanushali Studios, Legend Studios | - | 8.0 | A- |
Bhakshak | Bhumi Pednekar, Sanjay Mishra | Red Chillies Entertainment | Netflix | 7.8 | B+ |
Kaagaz 2 | Anupam Kher, Darshan Kumar | Satish Kaushik Entertainment | Venus Worldwide Entertainment | 7.5 | B |
Laapataa Ladies | Ravi Kishan, Nitanshi Goel | Aamir Khan Productions | Jio Studios | 7.4 | B |
Operation Valentine | Varun Tej, Manushi Chhillar | Sony Pictures International | Renaissance Pictures, God Bless Ent | 7.2 | B |
Ae Watan Mere Watan | Sara Ali Khan, Sparsh Srivastav | Dharmatic Entertainment | Amazon Prime Video | 7.0 | B- |
Bastar: The Naxal Story | Adah Sharma, Shilpa Shukla | Sunshine Pictures | - | 6.8 | B- |
Amar Singh Chamkila | Diljit Dosanjh, Parineeti Chopra | Window Seat Films | Netflix | 6.5 | C+ |
Shaitaan | Ajay Devgn, R. Madhavan, Jyothika | Devgn Films, Good Co. | Jio Studios, Panorama Studios | 6.3 | C+ |
1. Merry Christmas
Director: Sriram Raghavan
Strengths: Known for his mastery of suspense and psychological depth, Raghavan delivers a tightly woven narrative with layered characters. The film's emotional engagement is rooted in its complex relationships and thematic exploration.
Rating: 8.1/10
Grade: A-
2. Main Atal Hoon
Director: Ravi Jadhav
Strengths: A biographical drama led by Pankaj Tripathi, this film dives into the life of an iconic figure. Its believability and intellectual depth lie in its authenticity and heartfelt portrayal.
Rating: 8.0/10
Grade: A-
3. Bhakshak
Director: Pulkit
Strengths: A gritty narrative anchored by Bhumi Pednekar’s performance. The storytelling shines in its raw portrayal of social issues and its emotional weight.
Rating: 7.8/10
Grade: B+
4. Kaagaz 2
Director: V.K. Prakash
Strengths: The sequel to Kaagaz focuses on the importance of identity and bureaucracy. Its meaningfulness elevates its impact, though the pacing slightly hampers engagement.
Rating: 7.5/10
Grade: B
5. Laapataa Ladies
Director: Kiran Rao
Strengths: A unique, lighthearted narrative that cleverly comments on societal norms. It balances humor and depth, engaging audiences with its charm.
Rating: 7.4/10
Grade: B
6. Operation Valentine
Director: Shakti Pratap Singh Hada
Strengths: A patriotic action-drama with a strong narrative arc. While not as nuanced as others, it delivers on emotional engagement and relevance.
Rating: 7.2/10
Grade: B
7. Ae Watan Mere Watan
Director: Kannan Iyer
Strengths: This period drama is bolstered by its emotional depth and historical resonance, though its pacing can feel uneven.
Rating: 7.0/10
Grade: B-
8. Bastar: The Naxal Story
Director: Sudipto Sen
Strengths: A hard-hitting exploration of socio-political issues with strong performances. The storytelling is compelling, though occasionally heavy-handed.
Rating: 6.8/10
Grade: B-
9. Amar Singh Chamkila
Director: Imtiaz Ali
Strengths: This biopic captures the essence of a controversial figure with authenticity, though it occasionally falters in narrative cohesion.
Rating: 6.5/10
Grade: C+
10. Shaitaan
Director: Vikas Bahl
Strengths: A dark and thrilling narrative with emotional tension, though it lacks the finesse to reach its full potential.
Rating: 6.3/10
Grade: C+
Movies Rated 5.0/10 or Below and Graded "D" or Below
Based on our analysis data, 62 movies fall into this category. This accounts for approximately 43% of all releases, showcasing a high proportion of poorly rated films.
Why Such a Large Number of Productions Fail Miserably
Overproduction: With an average of 12 films released monthly, quantity often overtakes quality. Many films are rushed into production without adequate attention to storytelling or cinematic craft.
Lack of Strong Storytelling: Many movies fail to invest in emotionally engaging narratives or relatable characters, leading to shallow and uninspiring experiences.
Formulaic Approach: Recycled plots, overused tropes, and reliance on star power over substance dilute the audience’s connection to the films.
Marketing Over Content: Huge budgets are spent on marketing gimmicks to inflate initial interest, but the films themselves fail to meet audience expectations.
Weak Execution: Despite promising concepts, poor direction, subpar acting, and inconsistent technical quality derail the films' potential.
Audience Disconnect: A significant portion of releases cater to the lowest common denominator, neglecting audiences who crave more meaningful, intellectual, and globally relevant content.
Observations about the Indian Film Industry
Strength in Biopics and Realism: Films like Main Atal Hoon and Bhakshak show the power of authentic storytelling and grounded narratives.
Room for Thematic Exploration: While some films excel in presenting social or historical themes, others fall short in depth and execution.
Potential for Global Standards: To meet world-class benchmarks, focus must shift to nuanced character development, tighter pacing, and universal relevance without losing cultural specificity.
This analysis highlights the industry's potential and areas for growth in storytelling. While some films stand out, the overall craft of Hindi cinema still has room to match global cinematic excellence. With nearly 43% of releases scoring poorly, this year’s output raises urgent questions about the industry’s focus and its path forward. Can Indian cinema reclaim its global relevance by prioritizing storytelling craft over spectacle?
The Promise and Pitfalls of Indian Cinema on the Global Stage
As per the Executive Summary of the commercial filmed entertainment section in the FICCI M&E Report by EY released in 2024, India's film industry is a powerhouse of content, with over 1,700 films released annually and a burgeoning audience spanning 160 countries as of 2023. Yet, amidst this immense output, a glaring question emerges: why hasn't Indian cinema consistently dominated global accolades and viewership like its Hollywood counterparts? The report highlights an industry brimming with potential, bolstered by technological advances, growing digital audiences, and vibrant regional storytelling. However, a closer look at the storytelling craft reveals a persistent gap that hampers its ascent to the zenith of world-class filmmaking.
With theatrical revenues climbing to INR 120 billion and 339 Indian films released overseas in 2023, the appetite for Indian cinema exists. Yet, this growth is frequently undermined by an over-reliance on formulaic narratives and underdeveloped storytelling elements. Imagine the transformative potential if Indian filmmakers harnessed the power of authentic, emotionally resonant stories that align with universal themes while preserving their rich cultural essence. Such a shift could redefine Indian cinema, moving it from an "opportunity lost" to a beacon of global cinematic excellence.
Key Statistics and Observations:
Total Films Produced: Over 1,700 films released in 2023, marking India as a prolific content creator.
Global Reach: Indian films captivated audiences in 160 countries, topping streaming charts on global platforms.
Revenue Highlights: Theatrical revenues reached INR 120 billion, reflecting a growing domestic and international interest in Indian films.
Challenges in Craft: Despite quantitative growth, qualitative aspects like narrative innovation and emotional depth remain underdeveloped.
Path Forward: Leveraging Storytelling in a Disrupted Global Industry
To ascend as a global cinematic leader, the Indian film industry must prioritize storytelling excellence over volume. This requires a shift from formulaic narratives and under-talented star power to focusing on crafting authentic, emotionally resonant stories. Thematic relevance and universal appeal can bridge cultural and emotional gaps, making Indian cinema a true global contender.
In the current disruption of the global film industry, with AI integration revolutionizing story and storytelling craft, lies a small yet significant window of opportunity. AI-driven tools can augment creativity, providing insights into audience preferences, enhancing screenwriting processes, and streamlining narrative structures. This disruption offers the Indian film industry a chance to pivot toward innovation and craft-driven storytelling, moving away from overused tropes, superficial VFX spectacles, and formulaic scripts.
By leveraging AI to tell stories rooted in our shared humanity—tales that celebrate universal themes through the lens of India’s rich cultural diversity—the industry can create films that resonate globally. This requires investing in talent that understands the nuances of narrative artistry and abandoning the reliance on star power as a crutch. By embracing this mindset, Indian filmmakers can create products that transcend boundaries, reflecting the very essence of human experience while setting new benchmarks for cinematic excellence. The time to act is now—this is India’s moment to reclaim its storytelling legacy and shape the future of global cinema.
Conclusion
The 2024 Hindi films released highlight a concerning trend: while a few films excel in storytelling and execution, a significant number fail to meet even basic cinematic standards. To transform this landscape, the Indian film industry must prioritize quality over quantity, embrace originality, and focus on crafting films that resonate emotionally and intellectually with our shared humanity across the global audience. Only then can Indian cinema reclaim its legacy as a world-class storytelling powerhouse. And that is going to be a tall order given our current state of the film industry which is at an inflection point.
Comments